CinePulse – Movie Reviews & Entertainment
Materialists Review: A Look at Love’s Imperfections

Materialists Review: A Look at Love’s Imperfections

Romance Drama 2025 ⏱ 1h 56m
TMDB 6.3
Editor 6.3
HomeMaterialists Review: A Look at Love’s Imperfections
DirectorCeline Song
Year2025
Runtime1h 56m
LanguageEnglish (EN)
GenreRomance, Drama

Materialists backdrop
Materialists poster
  • Genre: Romance, Drama
  • Director: Celine Song
  • Year: 2025
  • Runtime: 1h 56m
  • Language: English (EN)
  • TMDB Rating: ⭐ 6.3/10

Movie Overview

In Celine Song's Materialists, Dakota Johnson shines as Mia, a driven matchmaker in New York City who prides herself on finding love for others while wrestling with her own romantic entanglements. When her former boyfriend, played by Chris Evans, unexpectedly re-enters her life, Mia finds herself torn between her current perfect match and the deep-seated feelings she still holds for her ex. This emotional tug-of-war leads her to question her own demands for perfection in relationships, especially when her latest matchmaking gig starts to unravel.

The conflict escalates as Mia's professional life collides with her personal struggles. A pivotal scene unfolds when she hosts a dinner party to introduce her latest couple, only to have Chris’s character show up, throwing the evening into chaos. The tension that builds around the dinner table showcases the film’s clever dialogue and the subtleties of unspoken emotions. Mia's interactions push her to confront the reality of her past choices versus her current path.

As Mia balances the expectations of her clients and her unresolved feelings, the story deepens, revealing layers of vulnerability in her character. The emotional climax occurs during a quiet moment on the rooftop, where Mia grapples with what she truly wants. The stakes feel high, as Song masterfully navigates Mia’s internal conflict. The runtime allows for moments that linger, inviting viewers to reflect on their own relationships.

But what stayed with me after the credits rolled was not just Mia's decision but the resonating question of what it means to truly connect with another person. The film closes with a suggestive ambiguity — leaving the audience pondering the tension between perfection and reality without rushing to a neatly tied ending.

Direction & Cinematography

Celine Song's direction in Materialists is both observant and intimate, giving viewers a front-row seat to Mia's emotional turmoil. One standout shot occurs during a bustling scene in a café where Song uses a long take as Mia overhears conversations around her, mirroring her internal conflict. The camera lingers just long enough on Mia’s contemplative expression, making us feel her isolation despite being surrounded by people.

The pacing is deliberate, allowing relationships to breathe. I noticed that the film often slows down during poignant moments, particularly in scenes where Mia reflects on her decisions. But in contrast, the lighter, comedic moments are quick-paced and sharp, which serves to highlight the weight of the heavier scenes. This balance keeps the film engaging, even during the slower moments.

What struck me most was how Song uses the city as a character in itself. The vibrant New York backdrop contrasts with Mia's internal struggles, emphasizing her feeling of being lost in a place that should feel like home. The duality of her personal journey against this vivid urban landscape adds layers to the storytelling that I appreciated.

Cast & Performances

Dakota Johnson embodies Mia with a relatable mix of ambition and vulnerability. Her open expressions during key moments — like when she hesitates at the rooftop scene — reveal the depth of her character's conflicts. Johnson's ability to communicate Mia’s internal struggle through subtle facial changes really elevates the emotional weight of the story.

Chris Evans brings an easy charm to his role as Mia's ex. One standout moment is his delivery of a line while they reminisce over shared memories — there’s a playful banter that captures their chemistry beautifully. However, I kept waiting for more depth to his character, as he sometimes feels more like a plot device than a fully realized person.

Pedro Pascal's supporting role as Mia's current romantic interest adds a lighthearted touch, though I wasn't expecting him to serve as a foil to Mia’s emotional journey. His reactions and line deliveries often provide comic relief, which works well, although there were scenes where I felt his character needed a bit more backstory to fully resonate with Mia's plight.

Character Psychology

Mia initially wants a successful career and the ideal relationship as a matchmaker, believing that love can be perfectly crafted. Yet, what she truly needs is to confront her past and understand that perfection in love is an illusion. As the film progresses, we see her navigate this journey with varying degrees of self-awareness.

Ultimately, Mia does change, but it’s a gradual realization. She moves from a desire for control over her relationships to embracing uncertainty and connection — though this evolution isn’t always clear, leaving some moments feeling incomplete.

Themes & Emotional Depth

Materialists dives into the complexities of love and the unrealistic expectations we place on relationships. The dinner party scene highlights Mia's struggle between expectations and reality, as her idealized vision of love crumbles around her. It’s a raw moment that lays bare the theme: love is messy and often falls short of our expectations.

Another key theme is the impact of past relationships on our current choices. Mia’s journey reflects how unresolved feelings can cloud judgment and how we often seek comfort in familiar patterns, even when they don’t serve our growth. The contrast between her past and present partners symbolizes this struggle, and it's a relatable conflict for anyone who has faced similar choices.

Memorable Scenes & Dialogue

One memorable scene takes place during Mia's dinner party, where a moment of silence stretches as Mia's past collides with the present. The awkward tension is palpable, and the ensemble cast shines in their reactions. This works because it highlights the film's strength in showcasing unspoken emotions, making us feel as uncomfortable as Mia does.

Another strong moment occurs on the rooftop, where Mia and Chris’s character share a heartfelt conversation about their relationship. The rooftop's cinematic backdrop amplifies the intensity of their exchange, framing it against the vastness of the city. This scene effectively captures the weight of their shared history, and Johnson’s performance here is particularly striking.

Finally, the closing shot is also noteworthy, lingering on Mia as she reflects under the city lights. It’s a beautifully composed shot that encapsulates her journey — a moment of clarity amidst chaos.

The Ending — Does It Deliver?

The ending of Materialists feels earned, as it ties back to Mia’s development throughout the film. The final moments, where she stands alone on the rooftop contemplating her choices, resonate deeply after everything she’s endured. I wasn’t expecting the ambiguity of her choice, but it feels like a true reflection of life — messy and uncertain.

What left me with a sense of bittersweet satisfaction was the way it underscored that love isn’t about perfection — it’s about the willingness to embrace complications. The final shot captures Mia's newfound acceptance, leaving us pondering what will come next for her.

What Works

One of the film's strengths is its ability to weave humor into deeper emotional narratives. The rooftop scene serves as a highlight, balancing tension and relief through clever dialogue. Johnson's performance, especially during her moments of vulnerability, shines brightly, making Mia’s journey feel relatable and real. Moreover, the cinematography effectively captures the vibrancy of New York, serving as a visual metaphor for Mia's internal chaos.

Honest Criticism

However, the subplot involving Mia’s clients can feel like a distraction from her primary arc. While intended to reflect her expertise, it often stalls the film's pacing and detracts from the emotional stakes. A couple of characters, particularly her clients, lack depth and resolution, making their inclusion feel somewhat superficial. It bothered me slightly that this element diluted the film's focus on Mia’s journey despite its potential to add richness.

How It Compares

Materialists can be compared to films like 500 Days of Summer and La La Land, both of which explore love's highs and lows. However, where Materialists stands apart is in its grounded portrayal of the aftermath of relationships. Unlike La La Land's grand musical flourishes, this film embraces a more realistic approach, making it relatable for modern audiences. That said, it lacks some of the immediate charm and wit that those films leverage, which may leave some viewers wanting more flair.

While 500 Days of Summer plays with narrative structure to explore its themes, Materialists opts for a more linear storytelling style, grounding itself in the day-to-day lives of its characters. In both cases, the exploration of love is relatable, but Materialists may not hit the same emotional highs that some viewers would seek.

Legacy & Cultural Impact

Though it's too early to fully gauge its legacy, Materialists has sparked discussions around the modern expectations of love and relationships. The film's release during a time when dating culture is rapidly evolving adds to its relevance. Critics seem mixed, as indicated by its 6.3/10 rating, yet it addresses themes that resonate widely today.

If it garners more attention in future awards seasons, it could reshape how romance is depicted in indie cinema, leading to deeper explorations of character and emotional truth.

Behind the Scenes

Dakota Johnson and Chris Evans reportedly improvised several lines during their rooftop scene, adding authenticity to their chemistry. The production faced budget constraints that limited shooting locations, prompting creative use of existing New York City spots. Interestingly, the script underwent significant changes post-casting, with Pedro Pascal's character being expanded to provide more comedic relief after initial readings showed strong audience reactions to his lighter tone.

Who Should Watch It?

This film will appeal to viewers who appreciate character-driven narratives that explore the complexities of love. If you enjoy subtle, realistic romances like Frances Ha or Before Sunrise, you’ll likely find Materialists engaging. However, those looking for a traditional romantic comedy with clear resolutions and plot-driven storytelling should probably skip it.

Final Verdict

Materialists offers a thoughtful exploration of the complexities of love and relationships, underscored by strong performances and a relatable narrative. While certain subplots falter in execution, the film succeeds in capturing the messiness of real-life emotions. If you’re in the mood for a reflective look at modern romance, this film is worth your time.

★★★☆☆ 6.3/10

Rate This Movie

Our rating: 6.3/10

Cast

Dakota Johnson
Dakota Johnson
Lucy
Chris Evans
Chris Evans
John
Pedro Pascal
Pedro Pascal
Harry
Zou00eb Winters
Zou00eb Winters
Sophie
Marin Ireland
Marin Ireland
Violet

Official Trailer