CinePulse – Movie Reviews & Entertainment
Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016): A Visual Feast That Stumbles on Story

Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016): A Visual Feast That Stumbles on Story

Adventure Family Fantasy 2016 ⏱ 1h 53m
TMDB 6.6
Editor 6.5
HomeAlice Through the Looking Glass (2016): A Visual Feast That Stumbles on Story
DirectorJames Bobin
Year2016
Runtime1h 53m
LanguageEnglish (EN)
GenreAdventure, Family, Fantasy

Alice Through the Looking Glass backdrop
Alice Through the Looking Glass poster

Movie Overview

Alice Kingsleigh returns to Underland, only to find her friend the Mad Hatter in dire straits. Diagnosed with a mysterious ailment, Hatter’s only hope lies in Alice retrieving a magical artifact: the Chronosphere. This device, capable of manipulating time, sets Alice on a race against the clock.

The journey takes her deep into the past, where she uncovers family secrets and unresolved tensions among Underland's inhabitants. Her interactions with Time himself, played by Sacha Baron Cohen, add a layer of urgency and existential weight.

What starts as a rescue mission evolves into a deeper exploration of forgiveness and the inevitability of change. Alice’s choices ripple through the timelines, affecting everyone she holds dear.

Yet, despite the high stakes, the narrative occasionally loses its footing, leaving viewers wondering if the adventure was worth the emotional investment.

Direction & Cinematography

James Bobin steps into Tim Burton's shoes with mixed results. The film’s visual palette is undeniably rich, filled with swirling colors and intricate designs. Bobin’s attention to detail shines in scenes like the Chronosphere’s introduction, where gears and clocks dominate the frame.

But pacing becomes an issue. The film’s middle section drags, bogged down by exposition and flashbacks. I kept waiting for the momentum to pick up, but it never quite does.

What struck me most was Bobin’s handling of Time’s character. Sacha Baron Cohen’s performance oscillates between comedic and poignant, and Bobin’s direction amplifies this duality. Yet, the tone feels inconsistent, veering from whimsical to somber without enough transition.

Cast & Performances

Mia Wasikowska anchors the film with a grounded portrayal of Alice. Her determination feels genuine, especially in scenes where she confronts Time. Her quieter moments, like when she reflects on her own family, add depth to an otherwise action-heavy role.

Johnny Depp’s Mad Hatter is more subdued here compared to the first film. While his eccentricities still entertain, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the character lacked the same spark. Depp’s emotional scenes, though, are surprisingly effective.

Anne Hathaway’s White Queen feels underutilized. Her ethereal presence adds charm, but the script gives her little to do. Helena Bonham Carter’s Red Queen, on the other hand, steals every scene she’s in with her over-the-top delivery and physicality.

Character Psychology

Alice wants to save the Hatter, but what she needs is to confront her own fears of loss and change. Her journey through time forces her to face these truths, even if she doesn’t fully realize it at first.

Yet, her growth feels uneven. By the end, Alice learns to accept the past, but the film doesn’t fully explore how this acceptance changes her. It’s as if the script stops short of digging deeper.

Themes & Emotional Depth

The film grapples with the idea of time as both a healer and a destroyer. Alice’s manipulation of the Chronosphere forces her to confront the consequences of her actions, highlighting the fragility of existence.

Family dynamics also play a central role. The strained relationship between the Red Queen and the White Queen serves as a mirror to Alice’s own fractured family ties. These themes, while compelling, often feel overshadowed by the film’s visual spectacle.

Memorable Scenes & Dialogue

The introduction of Time’s castle is a standout. The entire scene is a marvel of production design, with towering gears and ticking clocks creating a sense of urgency and wonder. Sacha Baron Cohen’s deadpan delivery adds a layer of humor.

Another memorable moment is Alice’s confrontation with the Red Queen. Helena Bonham Carter’s exaggerated expressions and delivery make the scene both hilarious and poignant. Her line, 'It’s better to be feared than loved,' sticks with you long after the credits roll.

The final shot of Alice sailing off to new adventures is visually stunning but feels a bit too tidy. It’s a beautiful image, but it lacks the emotional punch it could have had.

The Ending — Does It Deliver?

The climax hinges on Alice’s decision to return the Chronosphere, accepting the past as it is. This moment is earned, but it feels rushed. The emotional weight of her choice isn’t fully explored, leaving the resolution feeling incomplete.

What surprised me most was how quickly the film wraps up. After such a grand journey, the ending feels abrupt, almost as if the filmmakers weren’t sure how to conclude Alice’s arc. The final shot, while visually striking, left me wanting more.

What Works

The film’s visuals are stunning, especially the Chronosphere scenes. Mia Wasikowska’s performance keeps Alice relatable even in the most fantastical moments. Sacha Baron Cohen’s Time adds a unique twist, blending humor with existential dread.

Helena Bonham Carter’s Red Queen remains a highlight, bringing both comedy and pathos to her role.

Honest Criticism

The pacing in the middle section drags, bogging down the story. Johnny Depp’s Mad Hatter feels less vibrant compared to the first film. The ending, while visually impressive, feels rushed and emotionally unsatisfying.

How It Compares

Compared to Tim Burton’s 'Alice in Wonderland,' this sequel feels less cohesive. Burton’s film, while flawed, had a clearer narrative drive and a stronger sense of purpose.
'Maleficent' handles its heroine’s journey with more finesse, balancing spectacle with emotional depth. 'Alice Through the Looking Glass' tries to do the same but falters under its own ambition.
Visually, it surpasses both films, yet its story struggles to keep pace.

Legacy & Cultural Impact

Upon release, 'Alice Through the Looking Glass' was met with lukewarm reviews and modest box office returns. It didn’t capture the same cultural zeitgeist as its predecessor.

The film’s legacy lies in its visual achievements rather than its storytelling. It remains a testament to what modern CGI can accomplish, but it’s unlikely to be remembered as a classic.

Behind the Scenes

Johnny Depp’s Mad Hatter costume underwent several redesigns to better reflect the character’s deteriorating state. The final design included subtle changes like faded colors and frayed edges.

The Chronosphere’s design was inspired by real-life astronomical clocks, with the filmmakers studying ancient mechanisms to ensure accuracy.
Scenes involving Time’s castle were shot on location in England, with extensive green screen work to enhance the fantastical elements.

Who Should Watch It?

Fans of visually-driven fantasy films will enjoy the spectacle. Families looking for a whimsical adventure might find it entertaining.
Those seeking a tightly-woven narrative or deep emotional resonance should look elsewhere.

Final Verdict

While 'Alice Through the Looking Glass' dazzles with its visuals, it struggles to deliver a compelling story. The performances, particularly Mia Wasikowska and Helena Bonham Carter, elevate the material.
The film’s pacing and rushed ending detract from its overall impact. For fans of the first film, it’s worth a watch, but don’t expect it to surpass the original.

★★★☆☆ 6.5/10

Rate This Movie

Our rating: 6.5/10

Questions People Ask About Alice Through the Looking Glass (2016): A Visual Feast That Stumbles on Story

Cast

Mia Wasikowska
Mia Wasikowska
Alice Kingsleigh
Johnny Depp
Johnny Depp
Tarrant Hightopp / Mad Hatter
Anne Hathaway
Anne Hathaway
Mirana / White Queen
Helena Bonham Carter
Helena Bonham Carter
Iracebeth / Red Queen
Sacha Baron Cohen
Sacha Baron Cohen
Time

Official Trailer