CinePulse – Movie Reviews & Entertainment
Highlander (1986) Review: Flawed But Unforgettable Cult Classic

Highlander (1986) Review: Flawed But Unforgettable Cult Classic

Adventure Action Fantasy 1986 ⏱ 1h 56m
TMDB 6.9
Editor 8.2
HomeHighlander (1986) Review: Flawed But Unforgettable Cult Classic
DirectorRussell Mulcahy
Year1986
Runtime1h 56m
LanguageEnglish (EN)
GenreAdventure, Action, Fantasy

Highlander backdrop
Highlander poster

Movie Overview

Connor MacLeod (Christopher Lambert) should have died in 1536 Scotland when a brutal warrior ran him through. But he wakes up alive — and soon learns he's immortal, destined to duel others like him across centuries until 'there can be only one.' The film cuts between 16th century flashbacks and 1985 New York, where MacLeod, now an antiques dealer, prepares for a final showdown with his oldest enemy, the Kurgan (Clancy Brown).

What stayed with me after the credits is how the love stories hurt more than the sword fights. MacLeod loses two wives — one to mortality, one to his immortal curse — and Lambert plays these losses with quiet devastation. The Kurgan, meanwhile, relishes violence in ways that still feel shocking.

The police subplot with Roxanne Hart's Brenda barely works, but it gives MacLeod someone human to protect. Personally, I think the film's messy structure adds to its charm — like an old storyteller jumping between favorite memories.

That final battle in a parking garage? Worth every minute of the uneven buildup.

Direction & Cinematography

Russell Mulcahy, fresh from MTV music videos, directs with flashy confidence. The opening shot — a wrestling match under neon lights cutting to a 16th century battlefield — tells you exactly what tone to expect. On rewatch, I noticed how he frames immortals slightly larger than life, with low angles during duels that make their clashes feel mythic.

But the pacing stumbles whenever we linger too long in 1985. The police station scenes drag, and Brenda's character gets shortchanged. What surprised me most was how well the Scottish flashbacks work — the misty highlands and Sean Connery's eccentric Ramirez give the film its heart.

Mulcahy's best choice? Letting Queen's bombastic soundtrack underline every emotional beat. When 'Princes of the Universe' kicks in during the finale, you either surrender or resist — there's no middle ground.

Cast & Performances

Christopher Lambert's MacLeod shouldn't work — his accent veers between French and Scottish, his line readings are deliberately stilted. And yet, he makes you believe a man who's lived 400 years might move and speak like an alien. Watch how he handles antique swords versus battle weapons — the care feels lived-in.

Clancy Brown's Kurgan steals every scene. His grin when terrorizing a church or growling 'It's better to burn out than to fade away!' makes him one of the 80s' great villains. I wasn't expecting much from a punk-rock warlord, but Brown finds real menace in the role.

Sean Connery's Egyptian-Spaniard-Scottish Ramirez is pure nonsense — and completely irresistible. His sword training montage with Lambert stays just this side of self-parody. Roxanne Hart tries valiantly with thinly written Brenda, though her screaming during the climax didn't land for me.

Character Psychology

MacLeod wants to survive the Gathering — the final battle of immortals. What he needs is to accept that eternity means endless loss. His refusal to fight unless forced shows a man clinging to humanity in an inhuman contest.

The Kurgan, by contrast, embraces his monstrosity. He represents what MacLeod fears becoming — a predator who enjoys the hunt. Their final duel works because it's not just about skill, but whose vision of immortality wins.

Themes & Emotional Depth

Highlander is about outliving your world. MacLeod's antique shop full of artifacts from his past lives shows how immortality traps you in nostalgia. The film's best scene has him weeping over a 200-year-old love letter — Lambert plays it like the paper might dissolve if he touches it too hard.

It's also about masculinity as performance. The immortals adopt exaggerated personas (Ramirez's swagger, the Kurgan's brute force) to mask their loneliness. Only MacLeod's quiet grief feels authentic.

Memorable Scenes & Dialogue

1. The first duel: MacLeod fights another immortal in a parking garage, their swords sparking against concrete pillars. The editing cuts between thrusts and close-ups of Lambert's widening eyes — you feel his shock at surviving fatal wounds.

2. Ramirez's death: Sean Connery gets a heroic sendoff, laughing as he's impaled. The scene works because he underplays it — no grand speech, just a wink to his student.

3. The Kurgan's church invasion: Brown smashes stained glass while taunting MacLeod with 'You're a virgin!' It's ridiculous and terrifying in equal measure.

The Ending — Does It Deliver?

The final duel earns its spectacle by making the Kurgan feel unstoppable. When MacLeod finally beheads him, it's less triumphant than exhausting — Lambert slumps over like he's aged centuries in minutes.

What surprised me most was the quickening — the burst of energy that follows the killing. The special effects look cheesy now, but the idea that power comes with cosmic consequences still resonates. The last shot of MacLeod alone in the shadows stayed with me.

What Works

The sword fights choreographed by Bob Anderson (who trained Errol Flynn) blend historical technique with movie flair. The Kurgan's brutal hacking versus MacLeod's precise parries tells their character difference without words. Queen's score elevates every battle — 'Who Wants to Live Forever' during the flashback romance is peak 80s melodrama. And Lambert's strange performance grows on you; by the end, you can't imagine anyone else as MacLeod.

Honest Criticism

The modern-day police investigation feels tacked on — Roxanne Hart's Brenda exists mostly to be rescued. The editing jumps awkwardly between timelines in the first act, confusing first-time viewers. Worst offense: the 'quickening' effects during the finale look like a disco light show, undercutting the drama. A tighter focus on MacLeod and the Kurgan would've helped.

How It Compares

Highlander shares DNA with The Crow (1994) — both are stylish, music-driven fantasies about immortal vengeance. But where The Crow wallows in gothic grief, Highlander embraces absurdity. It's closer to Conan the Barbarian (1982) in tone, though it lacks that film's muscular coherence.

The film beats its imitators (like the sequels) by grounding its silliness in real pain. Where it falls short is the romantic subplot — Ladyhawke (1985) did immortal love better the same decade.

Legacy & Cultural Impact

Highlander flopped initially but found cult status on VHS, spawning sequels, a TV series, and endless memes ('There can be only one!'). Critics dismissed it in 1986, but its influence is undeniable — from Buffy's quippy monsters to superhero films' tragic immortals.

The Queen soundtrack went platinum, and 'Princes of the Universe' remains a stadium staple. It won the Academy Award for Best Sound Editing, oddly enough.

Behind the Scenes

  • Sean Connery filmed all his scenes in one week — his Ramirez wig is the same one he wore in The Name of the Rose (1986).
  • Clancy Brown based the Kurgan's voice on his father's military barks and John Belushi's Animal House growls.
  • The original cut ran 140 minutes; test audiences hated the extended love story, so Mulcahy trimmed it to 116.

Who Should Watch It?

Fans of 80s fantasy and unapologetic camp will adore this. If you love Conan, The Beastmaster, or Queen at their most theatrical, it's a must-watch. Viewers who prefer tight plotting or subtle acting should skip it — this is broadswords and bigger emotions.

Final Verdict

Highlander is a mess, but its best moments are legendary. I give it 8.2 for sheer audacity — where else can you see Sean Connery play a Spaniard teaching a Frenchman to be Scottish? The dated effects and uneven pacing keep it from greatness, but the central duel delivers. Watch it for Clancy Brown's villainy and the soundtrack alone.

★★★★☆ 8.2/10

Rate This Movie

Our rating: 8.2/10

Cast

Christopher Lambert
Christopher Lambert
Connor 'The Highlander' MacLeod
Roxanne Hart
Roxanne Hart
Brenda J. Wyatt
Clancy Brown
Clancy Brown
Victor 'The Kurgan' Kruger
Sean Connery
Sean Connery
Juan Sanchez Villa-Lobos Ramirez
Beatie Edney
Beatie Edney
Heather MacLeod

Official Trailer